Thankful for Disappointments and Success

This Thanksgiving, be thankful for both successes and disappointments. “Why?!,” you may retort.
In my morning time of prayer recently, I came across this Puritan prayer.
“Lord, I am blind and ignorant, and I cannot see through to the consequences. Things that I think are for my advantage may prove to be a snare and a curse. But in your infinite wisdom you know everything, so I resign my choice to you. Choose for me. And however your providence will order my affairs, make me then as thankful for disappointment as I ought to be for success.”[1]It resonated deeply with me. Because of my firm belief in God’s sovereign purposes and his providence, I should be thankful to him for the disappointments and successes in life. Like many, I’ve had both. I’ve seen successes. I’ve also seen disappointments. Like many, I defiantly want to resist failure and pursue success.
I think it is generally a good thing to pursue success rather than failure. Often pursuing success is a biblical response (e.g., loving our neighbor, faithfulness, providing for our families, etc.). Nevertheless, success can undoubtedly become an idol (and especially so in our culture). Moreover, we don’t always know what is best for us. Sometimes success is the worst thing for us spiritually.
Is this prayer for thankfulness in the midst of success and disappointment biblical?
Let’s examine five texts of Scripture to see if this prayer is in fact biblical.
(We will use Bible arcing to make some observations on each text. Let me remind you that each of these Scriptures have a specific context. That is why it is often wise to select the surrounding paragraph or two when studying.)
[1Th 5:16-18 ESV] – 16 Rejoice always, 17 pray without ceasing, 18 give thanks in all circumstances; for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you.
Series - rejoice, pray, and give thanks (all of the time and in all circumstances)
Ground - (statement) rejoice, pray, and give thanks always; (reason) it is God’s will
[Col 4:2 ESV] – 2 Continue steadfastly in prayer, being watchful in it with thanksgiving.
Idea/Explanation (potentially Action/Manner): continue in prayer; that is, with thanksgiving
[Eph 5:20 ESV] – 20 giving thanks always and for everything to God the Father in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ,
Series: giving thanks - always and for everything
[Phl 4:6 ESV] – 6 do not be anxious about anything, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God.
-/+ (negative/positive; not/but): (negative) don’t be anxious about anything; (positive) pray for everything with thanksgiving
[Rom 1:21 ESV] – 21 For although they knew God, they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him, but they became futile in their thinking, and their foolish hearts were darkened.
Alternative: when it became obvious that God exists and created all things, two alternative responses: (1) they did not honor him or thank him; but (2) they became foolish and futile.
Obviously, there are many more texts and ways we could approach evaluating this prayer biblically. However, according to these texts, we are to:
(1) give thanks always since it is God’s will;
(2) continue steadfastly in prayer with thanksgiving;
(3) give thanks always and for everything;
(4) not be anxious about anything, but pray with thanksgiving in everything;
and (5) thank God as we see him revealed in creation.
Therefore, yes, the prayer is biblical. This Thanksgiving release your disappointments, disasters, and anxieties into God’s providential hands. Thank him for successes and disappointments. He is working together a kind plan for his glory and your good (Romans 8:28). It will all work out favorably soon.
End Notes:
[1] Ezekiel Hopkins, “My Reason Employed for Your Truth,” Piercing Heaven: Prayers of the Puritans, ed. Robert Elmer (Bellingham, WA: Lexham Press, 2019), 53.



